So I was just reading some HP for no real good reason, and I had gotten to the part in HP 7 after Ron had dipset and H^2 were just chillin in Godric's Hollow (how harry never associated that with Gryffindor...these people would have been screwed without Hermione holy crap) and then 'arry was wondering about his parents' old house and whether or not he could see it, because
"he did not know what happened when the subjects of a Fidelius Charm died" (Rowling 323)UM OH YES YOU DO. Sirius' house was under the protection of the Fidelius Charm, and both he and the secretkeeper died prior to this 'thought,' so clearly Harry knows exactly what happens when the subject dies. I'm not asking for you to keep every damn detail accurate (especially wrt minute details like "omg harry got a cavity but nowhere in book 1 does it mention he forgot to brush!11!1!1!!!) but seriously JKR how you gon play sirius like this. And also get your astronomy right, you can't view Venus at midnight like they did for the OWLs.
No comments:
Post a Comment